The ABC Homeopathy Forum
Eczema 3 yrs old daughter Page 3 of 4
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Hi Rishimba
We gave her 21 doses(3 doses per day) be fore we saw some response and then we reported to you. After that we continued for almost one more week before stopping it completely. The total doses that we gave her was 39.
Regards
We gave her 21 doses(3 doses per day) be fore we saw some response and then we reported to you. After that we continued for almost one more week before stopping it completely. The total doses that we gave her was 39.
Regards
ursraj last decade
Hi!
Why a journey from Clematis to Arsenicum through Pulsatila when arsenicum could have been picked up right in the first instance by doing a differential diagnosis between Clematis and Arsenicum.We would have avoided all this by giving Arsincum in the first instance provided the aforesaid was done and the time for affecting a cure also would have been shortened avoiding the unnecessary aggravations through application of multiple doses(39!!) in number.I think the point is clear to you.
Why a journey from Clematis to Arsenicum through Pulsatila when arsenicum could have been picked up right in the first instance by doing a differential diagnosis between Clematis and Arsenicum.We would have avoided all this by giving Arsincum in the first instance provided the aforesaid was done and the time for affecting a cure also would have been shortened avoiding the unnecessary aggravations through application of multiple doses(39!!) in number.I think the point is clear to you.
sarup last decade
Thanks Mr Sarup for clarifying things. I really appreciate your suggestion.
How much time these aggravated rashes usually take to calm down?
How much time these aggravated rashes usually take to calm down?
ursraj last decade
Hi!
The cycle of aggravations in case of a similar medicine lasts shortly followed by a feeling of inner well being, vis-a-vis an improvement in the physical sufferings.
The cycle of aggravations in case of a similar medicine lasts shortly followed by a feeling of inner well being, vis-a-vis an improvement in the physical sufferings.
sarup last decade
i dont think we have given pulsatilla. did we?
it was kept as a third choice based on the PQRS but it was never given before ars alb.
correct me if i am wrong.
also, a 9c potency needs repetition and it really depends on the patient how many doses are required before we get a response. sometimes aggravations do happen, but there is no way out to exactly know the vitality of the patient before startting the treatment.
it was kept as a third choice based on the PQRS but it was never given before ars alb.
correct me if i am wrong.
also, a 9c potency needs repetition and it really depends on the patient how many doses are required before we get a response. sometimes aggravations do happen, but there is no way out to exactly know the vitality of the patient before startting the treatment.
♡ rishimba last decade
Hi Rishimba
We never gave Pulsatilla to our daughter. I do understand your approach and I don't have any complaints/problems with your suggestions. I hope in the next few days her aggravations will calm down and we start seeing some positive results.
We never gave Pulsatilla to our daughter. I do understand your approach and I don't have any complaints/problems with your suggestions. I hope in the next few days her aggravations will calm down and we start seeing some positive results.
ursraj last decade
Hi Rishimba
Just wanted to update you. Her rashes are not reducing. Usually she is better during daytime but it gets real bad in the night. Little while ago she scratched back of her knee joint and got some cuts. Also, now a days she cries for anything, and sometimes for no reason. Since last couple of days, she is also saying that she is sick. She had been complaining about throwing out but never really threw up.
Just wanted to update you. Her rashes are not reducing. Usually she is better during daytime but it gets real bad in the night. Little while ago she scratched back of her knee joint and got some cuts. Also, now a days she cries for anything, and sometimes for no reason. Since last couple of days, she is also saying that she is sick. She had been complaining about throwing out but never really threw up.
ursraj last decade
can you please describe her general nature.
- how she behaves with parents.
- with friends.
- with animals, dogs, pets etc.
- with insects, butterflies etc.
i am a little surprised why none of the indicated remedies are working.
i am wondering if a dose of TUBERCULINUM 1M would be helpful to clear any blocks !!
- how she behaves with parents.
- with friends.
- with animals, dogs, pets etc.
- with insects, butterflies etc.
i am a little surprised why none of the indicated remedies are working.
i am wondering if a dose of TUBERCULINUM 1M would be helpful to clear any blocks !!
♡ rishimba last decade
Dear Ursraj,
Sarup spoke wise words to you in an earlier post. Her condition would NOT be the way it is now if you had been prescribed 3 remedies to 'try'!!!! It does not work like that in homeopathy. Sarup believes Arsenicum suited your daughters totality of symptoms (meaning all her symptoms)and you should have given your daughter only a few doses of this remedy so her vital force could have cured or come closer to a cure of her eczema. 39 doses of the same remedy only makes things go slower and sometimes also impedes the cure. You were also told to 'try' another remedy and you didn't 'try' pulsatilla because you couldn't get any at the time- correct? Rishimba did want you to give this remedy to your daughter also. 3 different remedies in such a short amount of time only confuses the case and also gives your daughter more problems.
If you would like to keep following Rishimbas advice please feel free to do so but he does not follow the basic principles and practice of homeopathy (well not in your daughter's case anyway).
Sarup also said that Rishimba should have examined the two chosen remedies more closely to find the ONE that your daughter NEEDS and should NOT have got you to 'TRY' one after the other because he couldn't make up hes mind.
I had eczema for 12 years and also used cortizone and god knows what else. After taking a homeopathic remedy I was cured completely within a couple of weeks. I have been free from eczema for three years now.
Ursraj, there are a few very good homeopaths on this forum...you should ask Sarup for his advice or Sameer Vermani (he doesn't seem to mass prescribe like some) and his prescriptions actually work.
You can write a new post to Sameer and write in the heading that you need his help for your daughter.
I really do hope your daughter gets well asap.
Topaz
Sarup spoke wise words to you in an earlier post. Her condition would NOT be the way it is now if you had been prescribed 3 remedies to 'try'!!!! It does not work like that in homeopathy. Sarup believes Arsenicum suited your daughters totality of symptoms (meaning all her symptoms)and you should have given your daughter only a few doses of this remedy so her vital force could have cured or come closer to a cure of her eczema. 39 doses of the same remedy only makes things go slower and sometimes also impedes the cure. You were also told to 'try' another remedy and you didn't 'try' pulsatilla because you couldn't get any at the time- correct? Rishimba did want you to give this remedy to your daughter also. 3 different remedies in such a short amount of time only confuses the case and also gives your daughter more problems.
If you would like to keep following Rishimbas advice please feel free to do so but he does not follow the basic principles and practice of homeopathy (well not in your daughter's case anyway).
Sarup also said that Rishimba should have examined the two chosen remedies more closely to find the ONE that your daughter NEEDS and should NOT have got you to 'TRY' one after the other because he couldn't make up hes mind.
I had eczema for 12 years and also used cortizone and god knows what else. After taking a homeopathic remedy I was cured completely within a couple of weeks. I have been free from eczema for three years now.
Ursraj, there are a few very good homeopaths on this forum...you should ask Sarup for his advice or Sameer Vermani (he doesn't seem to mass prescribe like some) and his prescriptions actually work.
You can write a new post to Sameer and write in the heading that you need his help for your daughter.
I really do hope your daughter gets well asap.
Topaz
Topaz last decade
Hi Rishimba
It all depends upon her mood. Generally she is very playful and naughty. At times she is stubborn. When she is hungry or sleepy or getting bored then she will just do anything to trouble us and at that point she won't listen anything we say until we give our full attention to her. Usually when I am at home she is closer to me and a bit possesive about me too. Many a times she won't let her mom sit next to me.
She has not yet started going to school and don't have friends as such. Generally speaking with other kids in the neighborhood, she is ok. She takes her own time to mingle with other kids. She loves babies. She is also lil bit possessive about her stuffs and if some other kid touches it she complains to her mom and may be cry(depends).
She is generally afraid of animals and insects.
It all depends upon her mood. Generally she is very playful and naughty. At times she is stubborn. When she is hungry or sleepy or getting bored then she will just do anything to trouble us and at that point she won't listen anything we say until we give our full attention to her. Usually when I am at home she is closer to me and a bit possesive about me too. Many a times she won't let her mom sit next to me.
She has not yet started going to school and don't have friends as such. Generally speaking with other kids in the neighborhood, she is ok. She takes her own time to mingle with other kids. She loves babies. She is also lil bit possessive about her stuffs and if some other kid touches it she complains to her mom and may be cry(depends).
She is generally afraid of animals and insects.
ursraj last decade
Hi Topaz
I really appreciate your concerns and suggestions. Thanks a lot. Rather than starting a new thread I will prefer requesting dr sameer and dr saini to go through my daughter's case on this thread and guide us through her treatment.
Hi Dr. Sameer and Dr. Saini, please provide us your invaluable suggestions to guide us to treat my daughter's eczema.
I really appreciate your concerns and suggestions. Thanks a lot. Rather than starting a new thread I will prefer requesting dr sameer and dr saini to go through my daughter's case on this thread and guide us through her treatment.
Hi Dr. Sameer and Dr. Saini, please provide us your invaluable suggestions to guide us to treat my daughter's eczema.
ursraj last decade
Dear Ursraj,
It is not guaranteed that these other homeopaths will know that you are asking for their help. You are best writing a new post with their names in the heading and directing them to this thread (so you don't have to explain it all over again)
Your duaghter's case just might point to a nosode being used like Rishimba mentioned BUT i am a little concerned with the dose he suggested. In any case, get a second and even third opinion as it is your little baby girl that has to endure the prescriptions made for her.
All the best,
Topaz
It is not guaranteed that these other homeopaths will know that you are asking for their help. You are best writing a new post with their names in the heading and directing them to this thread (so you don't have to explain it all over again)
Your duaghter's case just might point to a nosode being used like Rishimba mentioned BUT i am a little concerned with the dose he suggested. In any case, get a second and even third opinion as it is your little baby girl that has to endure the prescriptions made for her.
All the best,
Topaz
Topaz last decade
ursraj,
i believe the mentals are ok for trying a dose of TUBERCULINUM 1M after a week or so.
tell me if the condition is now almost same as the start of the treatment or is it still aggravated.
please dont worry about the disturbance. in a forum like that these things will happen, you cant stop them.
i believe the mentals are ok for trying a dose of TUBERCULINUM 1M after a week or so.
tell me if the condition is now almost same as the start of the treatment or is it still aggravated.
please dont worry about the disturbance. in a forum like that these things will happen, you cant stop them.
♡ rishimba last decade
Dear Ursraj,
Please check out another post called '2.5 yrs old with eczema' and then make up your mind whether it is right for someone else to 'interfere' with your case....the prescribing methods in that thread are based on much analysis of the child 'as well as the mother when pregnant'!!!!!
Your daughter got eczema from the age of one month which means questions about you are necessary as well.
You can also post a question and ask in the thread of the 2.5 year old with eczema to please help you on your thread.
And sorry for the disturbance, but this case NEEDED disturbing!
Once again, all the best!
Topaz.
Please check out another post called '2.5 yrs old with eczema' and then make up your mind whether it is right for someone else to 'interfere' with your case....the prescribing methods in that thread are based on much analysis of the child 'as well as the mother when pregnant'!!!!!
Your daughter got eczema from the age of one month which means questions about you are necessary as well.
You can also post a question and ask in the thread of the 2.5 year old with eczema to please help you on your thread.
And sorry for the disturbance, but this case NEEDED disturbing!
Once again, all the best!
Topaz.
Topaz last decade
Hi Rishimba
Her rashes are still aggravated and today her face looks very reddish. If it gets itchy then I am sure by tomorrow morning she will have some cuts on her face.
Her rashes are still aggravated and today her face looks very reddish. If it gets itchy then I am sure by tomorrow morning she will have some cuts on her face.
ursraj last decade
ok, we will have to wait for a week more and then see the situation.
for now, please give her one dose of NUX VOM 12C at night for three nights.
please inform me if the rashes reduce in the next 3 days.
for now, please give her one dose of NUX VOM 12C at night for three nights.
please inform me if the rashes reduce in the next 3 days.
♡ rishimba last decade
Hi Rishimba
It will take a week or two to get the medicine. I will order NUX VOM 12C today. DO you want me to get TUBERCULINUM 1M too?
It will take a week or two to get the medicine. I will order NUX VOM 12C today. DO you want me to get TUBERCULINUM 1M too?
ursraj last decade
yes, if the rashes are not getting cured even after the aggravation is over, i would assume there is a miasmatic blockage which ars alb is not able to remove.
TUBERCULINUM 1M will be given after the condition stabilises.
if the aggravation is really due to ars alb, it should get relieved after a few doses of nux.
TUBERCULINUM 1M will be given after the condition stabilises.
if the aggravation is really due to ars alb, it should get relieved after a few doses of nux.
♡ rishimba last decade
ursraj last decade
Hi Rishimba
Since the medicines will take some time to arrive, meanwhile, as per sameer's suggestion, I'm giving my daughter some doses of pulsatilla. What is your opinion?
Since the medicines will take some time to arrive, meanwhile, as per sameer's suggestion, I'm giving my daughter some doses of pulsatilla. What is your opinion?
ursraj last decade
ok, you can give some doses of pulsatilla and see whats happening.
however, a dose of nux at night for two days could have reduced the aggravation if its really due to ars alb.
however, a dose of nux at night for two days could have reduced the aggravation if its really due to ars alb.
♡ rishimba last decade
Hi Rishimba
I would have given NUX as per your suggestion but the only problem is it will take some time to get it.
I would have given NUX as per your suggestion but the only problem is it will take some time to get it.
ursraj last decade
If Rhus Tox 30 removed the rashes in the first place, then just give her one dose of Rhus Tox 1M and don't repeat.
Stop all other meds.
Pankaj Varma
Stop all other meds.
Pankaj Varma
♡ PANKAJ VARMA last decade
Hi Pankaj
Thank you for your suggestion. Right now we are giving her Pulsatilla as per Sameer's suggestion.
Once again thank you!
Thank you for your suggestion. Right now we are giving her Pulsatilla as per Sameer's suggestion.
Once again thank you!
ursraj last decade
Hi Ursraj,
I have same story like yours. My daughter has eczema since she was 2 months, now she is 14 months. She really have severe eczema and we have done everything which was told or heard.
I was wondering how your daughter is doing? Is her eczema any better. I know you have posted this message about a year and really hope she is doing good.
Do you mind if you can share your success story (relief)? I really need help for my daughter.
I live in Orange county, CA. Please let me know if got any help.
Regards,
Surbi
I have same story like yours. My daughter has eczema since she was 2 months, now she is 14 months. She really have severe eczema and we have done everything which was told or heard.
I was wondering how your daughter is doing? Is her eczema any better. I know you have posted this message about a year and really hope she is doing good.
Do you mind if you can share your success story (relief)? I really need help for my daughter.
I live in Orange county, CA. Please let me know if got any help.
Regards,
Surbi
surbi last decade
surbi,
please take a questionnaire and fill it up with all details required to know the exact skin conditions, texture, looks, sensations when worse, modalities etc.
also write an essay on your child's mentals, personality, her behaviour and response to different conditions.
the reason i am telling this is because, every patient is different with respect to the totality of symptoms and thus may or may not respond to the same remedy.
once we come to know her totality, an individualised approach in her treatment can be taken.
please take a questionnaire and fill it up with all details required to know the exact skin conditions, texture, looks, sensations when worse, modalities etc.
also write an essay on your child's mentals, personality, her behaviour and response to different conditions.
the reason i am telling this is because, every patient is different with respect to the totality of symptoms and thus may or may not respond to the same remedy.
once we come to know her totality, an individualised approach in her treatment can be taken.
♡ rishimba last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.