seek classical homeopath to suggest me the treatment _{Page 3 of 6}

Yes.

Ok. Report after taking Ledum.pal.

I tried so far based on clinical indications. Obviously it is not helping.

We will try the constitutional approach. Give me a day's time.

If the pain is unbearable, take ibuprofen, a few doses. If ice is helping, continue with it.

Let me know, what medicines you are taking now, both allopathic and homeopathic.

I also requested Dr. Kulkarni, to have a look at your case. He is the best qualified doctor on the forum today.

Let us wait for his opinion.

Dear Murthy, please see if Calcarea Carb fits the case.

Did you take any allopathic medicines for pain relief?

Ok. Please list out all the medicines, You are taking currently.

This is suggested by Dr.Kulkarni.

Presently I am at a place wehre there is no good internet speed, though I have read this case completely I was unable to read the follow up which I will do once I have good internet access.

But on basis of the my study I would suggest this patient Pulsatilla 30C or 200C, just 2 doses 3 hours apart and wait for at least 8-10 days. No more medicines.

I hope this is his remedy. Let's see how this works.

He also should do some physical exercise which is important for him.

Please do as suggested and report after a week.

Also avoid taking aurvedic medicines.

Don't stop blood pressure medicines.

NIIEV16,
Please start with following prescription:

1. PULSATILLA 200C , pills (buy minimum qty dispensable at the shop), take 5 pills (for one dose) A SINGLE DOSE ONCE ONLY, (NO EXCESS DOSES PLEASE).
Nothing else to eat or drink 1 hour before and 1 hour after the doses.
(This dose works for several days. So, keep patience).


Do’s & don’ts:
1. Stay away from Strong odors.
2. Do not touch medicines or spill them. Use the cap of container (of same medicine) to transfer the medicines.
3. Place the prescribed dose under the tongue and let it dissolve. Keep the dose for at least 2 minutes in mouth.
4. Keep medicine containers airtight, away from direct sunlight, heat, any smell and children.
5. Avoid strong smells and odors AFAP.
6. Do not take any other medicines for any health problems. Most symptoms go as they come within 24-72 hours. Do not apply any cream etc for skin itching / eruption, if any.
7. Report any problems & seek appropriate advice.
8. Otherwise report progress after 1week.

You may continue BP medicine for a while but keep watch on BP.

Your problems are chronic, deep seated and age related. So, there is a long way to go before you can be reasonably alright.

When you report progress (or whatever) I wish you do so in comparative way. If you tell me before and after condition of each symptom you mention it will give me clear idea. If anything has occurred new, mention so.

During the course of treatment your present problems are likely to worsen for a while (which is actually good) and your old problems are likely to return (good again). But you need to keep patience. Do not do anything to relieve them.

At present it is a good sign that you are feeling bit motivated. But it is little early to expect anything more.

My queries:
Are your dreams old or new? Is there any, however little, change in their occurrence?
Is your toe pain more than what it was before taking the medicine?

I am sorry for sharing my opinion here but I felt compelled to add my two bits here afterreading the case history.I hope it would be taken in right spirit of open logical discussions I have witnessed on this forum.

Homeopathy looks at the complete person with the idea being that a particular dilution mimics his persona and can nudge him towards balance.
The so called constitution remedy is prescribed in chronic cases with this belief.In acute cases only symptoms matching dilution might work.

However there is no explanation for the origin or root cause of illness.If we do not know the root cause then how can we treat a person fully.I understand that the constitutional remedy is supposed to " take care of everything" without bothering about the underlying cause but it is hardly reassuring that without knowing root cause all would be well.

Ayurveda also looks at the complete person but it also explains pathogenesis and its spread through dhatus and channels.
It is far more simple than homeopathy but nonetheless deep and extensive.

I would advise here that it seems a case of primary vata derangement. It would help if the following are confirmed:

Constipation , fear, anxiety,worry, fundamental sensitivity to cold, originally thin or underweight, if weighty then flabby tissues, loses weight easily, worst aggravation 2-6 am and 2-6 pm,
Possible cracks on tongue, light sleeper, irregular activity, flexibility and changeability, dryness, gas, pain especially shifting pain, etc. I can go on and on.

I request to kindly confirm above.

tuepne,

This is an open forum. Anyone can express one's views. But while doing so one should bear in mind not to be unprofessional, misleading, prejudiced, offensive, etc.

As far as I understand you are still a learner. I have even replied your queries in other thread. I could make out that you are somewhat biased about homeopathy. Had you understood homeopathy completely and properly you wouldn't have said what you have said about 'cause of disease'.

I have studied all three - allopathy, homeopathy and ayurved - very closely (Though Ayurved little less) and know merits and limitations of each one. But have seen results of ayurved and I really appreciate and respect the system. Moreover, being the most ancient Indian system of medicine I have special regards for it.

But that doesn't mean homeopathy lacks or is substandard. In fact, the principles of both these system go parallel / hand in hand to each other; only the presentation and terminologies differ. You need to study each one thoroughly and unbiased to understand this. Probably, you are finding it bit more difficult to learn and understand homeopathy, which is possible. Hence is your prejudice.

However, I appreciate your enthusiasm. But I would like to suggest you not to venture suddenly in advising treatments at your stage, though the forum is the best place to do so. Rather, you can be a keen observer which will give you lot of practical knowledge. It is not only unprofessional and imprudent to jump into a stream of thread and express biased opinion. We professionals can understand each others' intentions but think about the person at the receiving end. The patients will get distracted and disturbed buy such comments, their faith will be shaken. you may comment if something grossly wrong is happening, if you see someone giving a hazardous advise but prejudiced comment can be very well refrained.